Before we get started today I want to disclaim: I have my opinions and they are just opinions, nothing more. You have every right to disagree; disagreement makes the world go round or something. But this is the world as I see it.
Okay! Let's talk about anti-Zionism as a thing that baffles me greatly. I have a friend at school whose political opinions I find rather confusing. He's Jewish, he was raised Jewish, he went to Jewish school like all the other good little Jews here. And yet on Facebook his political views are listed as anti-Zionist. He wants to live in Israel and not make aliyah (becoming a citizen of Israel). He is constantly posting articles that detail all the wrongs that the Israelis have perpetrated against the Palestinians.
Now here's the thing: I understand the desire of the Palestinian people to have a homeland because basically the Jews wanted the same thing not so long ago. They deserve to have a country to make their own; possibly they should have part of the land that we now call Israel - but that's not the point. I think in general everyone rational can see that the situation in the Middle East with the Palestinians and the Israelis can't go on.
What I can't understand is believing that the Jews don't deserve a homeland, and that Israel should not belong to them. I think my friend considers himself a relatively well-informed guy, but if that's the case, how can anyone believe that the situation during the Diaspora, even before the true awfulness of the Holocaust, was in any way okay. Because let me tell you guys, thanks to Professor Mendelsson and my history of Israel class, I can now tell you authoritatively that it was not okay! Anti-Semitism was a long-standing, even supported tradition in many countries, especially Russia and the rest of Eastern Europe (little though it may have been at the time, seeing as Russia pretty much was Eastern Europe). The situation of the Jews in any country, where rationalizing hatred of them by claiming that they were another species entirely and therefore completely incompatible with "regular" people, was not good, friends. It was not good!
So what I'm saying is this: how can a Jew who is not an Orthodox Jew (and who therefore believes that Jews coming to Israel is like trying to force the coming of the Messiah, which is wrong) not believe in Zionism? I just don't get it! His people, my people, our people needed a home, a refuge from the hatred that I am now starting to see was unfortunately pervasive.
And okay, if that all doesn't convince you, well then there's the Holocaust! I think that's pretty good proof that the world was, at least at the time, very much not inclined to be nice to the Jews.
In any case, I'm sorry to get all political on you guys, but it's just been bugging me! So I got it out. Now let's talk about other things, like for example the sick amount of Gilmore Girls I've been watching. Really! It's terrible! But I can't help it, Gilmore Girls is my comfort tv and I love it. What's your comfort tv? Or comfort something else?
Wednesday, March 3, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The difference, however, between Palestinians wanting a homeland and Jews wanting a homeland is that the Palestinians had a homeland and it was taken away from them. Just my thought.
ReplyDeleteTechnically it wasn't taken away from them. Palestinians still live here, although not necessarily in the best conditions, of course. And it's not like the Israelis didn't make plenty of attempts to find a solution. From what I know, which I admit is very little, the solutions that Israel proposed were all shot down by the Palestinians, because half apparently wasn't enough.
ReplyDeleteUgh I hate this discussion.
Really complicated issue. All I can say is Hamas makes my mind up for me. I don't know enough about anything else to really say anything.
ReplyDeleteAs for comfort TV, I'm making you watch an episode of "Felicity" next semester. It's about college at NYU and love triangles and it's adorable. GG is a good choice, though. I freaking love Lorelei.
What do you mean Hamas makes up your mind for you? I'm not sure I understand haha.
ReplyDeleteOh man I've heard of Felicity! I will watch it, mostly because I love Keri Russell! GG is a great choice. I can't decide who I love more! Did you watch Lauren Graham in the pilot to that new show Parenthood? She was good! And not Lorelai!
oh, sorry. That was really vague and confusing (partly because I don't know many details and can only argue what I feel about it, which can't really be backed up). I mean that Israel has to worry about constant threat and violence from terrorist groups like Hamas, and I don't believe there is a similar Israeli group. I feel like Israel does deserve a homeland, and the fighting is only going to stop with some compromise and concession. From what I've read, concession isn't something that Palestine (or factions of Palestine, because I'm sure there are many sides) is particularly willing to do. What I meant by Hamas is that I don't agree with how they handle the conflict (obviously), and their actions sway my thinking. I know not all Palestinians are Hamas. It's a complicated, deep seated issue that I know little about, but that's just how I feel.
ReplyDeleteYes, you must watch it. I love Keri Russell too! She's so freaking adorable in the show too. I didn't see Parenthood but I hear all about it from my mom. My mom loves Lauren Graham haha (I do too, of course). I should watch it though! :)
Yeah I get that! Hamas is generally what I worry about too hahaha. I don't think rational people blame regular Palestinians for all the stupid things their "government" decides to do, although of course there are Palestinians who support them, duh. Anyways. Hamas sucks, the end.
ReplyDeleteI will! It's long isn't it? And yeah, Lauren Graham is pretty great.
I BELIEVE it's just four seasons, because the pilot starts with her high school graduation and each season is "freshman year", "sophomore year", etc. I watched it all in one summer haha. I have them all on DVD too so if you ever want to borrow any of it, I've got your back. Just not while you're in Israel, obviously haha. Oh I'm excited.
ReplyDeleteSounds good! I would love to borrow the dvds, maybe when I come home! We can talk about them at Breakthrough. :)
ReplyDeleteomg I hope! We'll see at by the end of the month! :) Your shirt is badass btw. I can't tell you anything else about it because Sarah would kill me, but Sarah and I spent a lot of time on it and we're not even done yet! We're making is special.
ReplyDeleteI would be shocked if you didn't make it! And yay! I am so excited I can't wait! Haha I bet it's fabulous. I love you two.
ReplyDelete